The Real Estate Hunger Games

Surviving (and Thriving!) in a Multiple Offer Scenario

So you’re selling your house and you get an offer out of nowhere that seems too good to be true. What gives? Welcome to the world of “bully offers” in real estate.

A bully offer is an offer that a buyer submits on a property before the seller has officially listed or advertised it. Bully offers often come in above asking price and with very few contingencies. The goal is to tempt sellers into accepting quickly before they even have a chance to get competing offers.

For sellers, bully offers can seem awesome at first glance. I mean who wouldn’t want an over-asking, no strings attached offer plopped in their lap? But bully offers also require rapid decision making since sellers don’t have the benefit of shopping around offers or setting an offer date.

So how do you know if accepting a bully offer is the right move? That’s what we’ll explore in this guide. Understanding bully offers is crucial for any real estate seller navigating today’s competitive housing market. Let’s dive in!

What is a bully offer?

Time is of the essence when receiving a bully offer.

In the realm of real estate, a “bully offer” characteristically refers to a hard-hitting proposal made on a property prior to its official listing period. Indeed, this kind of offer seeks to influence the seller into accepting the assertive proposition rather than waiting to evaluate all the offers on the agreed date.

Subsequently, a bully offer is placed predominantly early in the home sale process, occasionally even preceding the official listing of the property on the market. It aspires to entice the seller with favorable terms and conditions which seem too attractive to decline.

Ultimately, the central objective of a bully offer is exerting pressure on the seller to accept this proposal before any rivaling offers appear. It endeavours to “bully” the seller into forgoing the standard procedure of listing the home and assessing all bids on a specific date.

The bully offer will typically contain very favorable terms for the seller. This includes things like waiving contingencies, providing a large earnest money deposit, closing quickly, and sometimes even offering more than the asking price. The idea is to make the offer so enticing that the seller feels compelled to accept on the spot.

By getting the seller to take the home off the market early, a bully offer prevents other potential buyers from making competing bids. It boxes out the competition preemptively through an aggressive first strike.

When Do Bully Offers Tend to Happen?

Whether to take a bully offer or not is a risky move.

Bully offers frequently occur when the housing market is highly competitive and inventory is low. In a seller’s market with surging demand and limited housing supply, buyers end up fiercely competing for desirable homes.

With more buyers than available properties, bidding wars erupt. Buyers try to gain an edge and make their offer stand out by submitting a bully offer before the seller officially puts the home on the market or starts reviewing bids. Bully offers aim to swoop in early with a tempting above-asking price bid to entice sellers to accept immediately before they field multiple competing offers.

The strategy preys on low inventory conditions where sellers may be inclined to jump on an early, inflated offer instead of risking a potentially lower bid in an official bidding war. Bully offers pop up most in tight housing markets where competition is cutthroat, supply is sparse, and buyers are eager to clinch a purchase amid scarce options. These tactics arise as demand outpaces supply.

Pros of accepting a bully offer

Accepting a bully offer can provide some nice perks for the seller. Here are some of the key advantages:

  • Receive an offer above asking price – One of the main draws of a bully offer is that it typically comes in above the listing price for the home. This allows the seller to garner a higher sale price.

  • Potentially avoid contingencies – Bully offers sometimes waive contingencies like financing, appraisal, and inspection. This takes some of the uncertainty out of the deal for the seller.

  • Lock in a buyer – Accepting a bully offer takes the home off the market immediately and locks in a buyer. This provides some security for the seller instead of waiting for the offer date.

  • Prompt closing – Bully offers may also propose a quick closing timeline. This allows the seller to complete the sale faster.

  • Avoid effort of sorting through multiple offers – Accepting a bully offer early can allow the seller to skip the process of reviewing, comparing, and negotiating multiple offers. It makes the transaction simpler.

So in summary, bully offers allow sellers to capitalize on an offer above list price with limited contingencies and quick closing. This can make the deal very appealing.

Cons of accepting a bully offer

Bully offers in real estate mean to choose the money or wait for more offers.

Accepting a bully offer can limit your ability to market the home to other potential buyers. Here are some key downsides to keep in mind:

  • Limited Exposure: Once you accept a bully offer, you take the home off the market. This means other buyers don’t get a chance to view the property or make competitive offers that could potentially drive up the price.

  • Rushed Decision-Making: With a bully offer, you need to make a quick decision about accepting or rejecting it. This doesn’t allow much time to carefully weigh all options or wait for scheduled offer dates.

  • Unknown Market Value: Accepting an early bully offer means you may not know the full market value of the home. Without letting the home sit on the market for a bit, you lose out on the chance to get market feedback and understand buyer demand.

  • Losing Leverage: Taking a bully offer right off the bat can mean losing leverage. If you get an offer you like early on, you may be tempted to take it, even if waiting a bit could spur a bidding war and higher offers.

  • Preventing Backup Offers: Once you accept an offer, it’s off the table for other buyers. This stops you from using other offers to negotiate or as backup options if your first deal falls through.

Overall, accepting a bully offer can be risky since it takes away your ability to fully market the home and leverage multiple interested buyers. Make sure to carefully weigh if it’s worth giving up exposure and competitive bidding before signing on the dotted line.

Pros of Rejecting a bully offer

Rejecting a bully offer and waiting to review all offers on the scheduled date gives you some key advantages as a seller. Here are some of the main pros of rejecting a bully offer in real estate:

  • Ability to Market More Widely: Rejecting early bully offers allows you to continue marketing the home as planned and generate even more interest among buyers. With more potential buyers in the mix, you have a greater chance of receiving multiple competitive offers and driving up the final sale price.

  • Stick to Your Schedule and Process: By rejecting premature bully offers, you can stay on track with your planned offer date and process. This allows everything to proceed in an organized fashion, avoiding rushed decisions.

  • Equal Opportunity for All Buyers: Waiting for the scheduled offer date gives every interested buyer an equal shot at making their best offer. A bully offer tries to gain an unfair advantage by jumping ahead of others.

  • More Time to Evaluate Options: Having all offers on the table by the scheduled date gives you more time to carefully evaluate each one. You don’t have to make a rushed decision and can optimize the outcome.

  • Avoid Setting a Precedent: Rejecting bully offers sends a message that you will not be pressured into accepting early offers. This can discourage other aggressive premature offers down the line.

By saying no to bully offers initially, sellers maximize their strategic position in a multiple offer scenario. Patience and sticking to the process pays off in the long run.

Cons of rejecting a bully offer

Which path do you take. The path of accepting the bully offer or wait until the offer day and see what other offers come in.

Rejecting a bully offer does come with some risks that a seller should consider. The main potential downside is that you may lose a guaranteed higher offer that is already in hand.

By turning down a bully offer and waiting for the scheduled offer date, other buyers may not come in as competitively. There is no certainty that you will receive better offers down the line. The bully offer likely came in above list price and with favorable terms precisely to entice the seller to accept before considering other buyers.

So while the intention may be to wait and generate more market interest, rejecting an early bully offer could backfire. The offer in hand represents money on the table that could disappear if you gamble on attracting higher bids later. Essentially, a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush.

Turning down a seemingly excellent offer does mean giving up a sure thing for the uncertainty of the future. The bully offer provided a clear path to a profitable sale. Without it, the sale becomes dependent on the motivation, budget and competitiveness of unknown potential buyers.

Questions to Ask about a bully offer

When presented with a bully offer, it’s important for sellers to ask their real estate agent key questions to fully understand the offer details. Here are some important questions sellers should consider:

  1. What are the exact terms of the bully offer? Make sure you understand the proposed purchase price, contingencies, closing date, and any special requests.

  2. Is the buyer prequalified? Ask if they have been preapproved for a mortgage and have the funds needed for a down payment. This helps gauge how serious they are.

  3. Why is the buyer in a rush? Understanding their motivation can provide useful context for weighing the bully offer.

  4. What happens if I reject the offer? Will it discourage other buyers? Will the buyer come back with a stronger offer? Know the implications.

  5. What are the risks of accepting early? You may lose out on a better offer down the line. Make sure you understand the tradeoffs.

  6. How does it compare to other offers? If you already have other offers in hand, compare terms side-by-side.

  7. What is your agent’s advice? Lean on your agent’s expertise in navigating bully offers and negotiating the best deal.

Asking the right questions upfront will help you make an informed decision about how to respond to a bully offer. Don’t feel pressured – take time to understand all angles before you decide.

Tips for Handling a bully offer

When faced with a bully offer on your home, it’s important to respond strategically. Here are some tips for navigating this situation smoothly:

  • Consult your agent. Your real estate agent can provide guidance on how to handle the offer. They have experience dealing with bully offers and can advise if it’s worth seriously considering or rejecting.

  • Act quickly. Bully offers expect fast responses, so try to evaluate the offer and make a decision within 24-48 hours if possible. The longer you wait, the more the buyer may get impatient and retract their offer.

  • Consider contingencies. Examine what contingencies, if any, are attached to the bully offer. Offers without contingencies like inspections and appraisals are more likely to result in a quick and smooth closing.

  • Compare to other offers. If you already have other offers in hand, compare the bully offer to them. A bully offer may not necessarily be the best just because it came first. Evaluate all factors like price, terms, and contingencies.

  • Negotiate terms. Don’t be afraid to try negotiating with the buyer on the bully offer, especially if you feel it could be sweeter. They may be open to compromising on areas like price, closing date, etc.

  • Trust your gut. If your gut says the bully offer is too good to pass up, go with it. But if you’re uncertain, listen to that instinct and wait for more offers. Don’t let pressure make the decision for you.

With some preparation and advice from your real estate professional, bully offers don’t have to be intimidating. Take the necessary steps to make a choice that works in your favor.

closing summary

When selling a home, having a solid understanding of bully offers is critical for navigating the sales process effectively. Though bully offers can seem pushy or overly aggressive, they are a legitimate tactic that buyers may use to secure a desired property.

All in all, by learning how bully offers work and the pros and cons of accepting them, sellers can make informed decisions that align with their goals. The initial offer on a new listing often sets the tone for future offers, so weighing all options thoughtfully is key. Being prepared for bully offers also reduces the stress of the sales process. While selling any property involves many factors to juggle, arming yourself with knowledge of bully offer best practices helps ensure your real estate transaction unfolds smoothly. With insight into bully offer strategies, sellers can feel empowered in choosing the right buyer for their most valuable asset.

Visit our blog to learn more things real estate!

Compare listings

Compare